Controversial Commonside Tesco planning appeal lodged

A planning appeal by Tesco to build a convenience store at Commonside is currently in process.

In 2006, Friends of the Earth submitted a report accusing Tesco of “manipulating the planning system” and “leaving councillors powerless” in its plans to expand the number of stores across the UK – a corporate strategy that has sparked controversy. Apparently not satisfied with having two stores already situated within easy reach of the area, Tesco is now appealing Sheffield City Council’s decision of 8th July 2009 to reject its application to build a further convenience store at Commonside.

Tesco originally applied in March 2009 to erect a two-storey building on the site of 218 Springvale Road, formerly belonging to Hollies Filling Station.

Statutory consultation attracted written representations from hostile locals including letters, a petition signed by nearly 1,700 people and an objection by Cllr Paul Scriven (Leader of Sheffield City Council).

Opponents’ worries included:

  • Unfair competition against local retailers, potentially pushing them out of business. These include a bakery, florist, greengrocer, newsagent, off-licence, wholefoods cooperative and more.
  • Money draining out of the local community and Tesco, a national chain store, not being accountable to the local community.
  • Increased traffic – including large delivery vehicles – in an area where there is a five-road junction and a nearby primary school.
  • Increased air pollution and heightened risk of road accidents.
  • Existing pressure on local retailers from the nearby Cooperative store.

Sheffield City Council’s refusal of the application was primarily due to the residential nature of the area, noise issues and increased traffic concerns.

Tesco filed its appeal against the decision on 6th January 2010 and there is a 17th February deadline for statements and representations, to be followed by a subsequent Inquiry (no date designated yet) into evidence and proofs before a final decision is reached.

North West Sheffield News Blog contacted the planning consultancy acting as agents for Tesco to ask for reasons behind the appeal but no-one is yet available for comment (and an update will be posted here if and when …).

If this particular appeal is successful, it will clearly illustrate the nature of power imbalances between private interests and local democracy.

You can follow the appeal’s progress here. To find out more, contact the Planning Inspectorate Customer Support Line on 0117 372 6372, quoting reference APP/J4423/A/09/2119387.

(Special thanks to SAUL for alerting NWS News Blog to this story via Twitter)


8 responses to “Controversial Commonside Tesco planning appeal lodged

  1. Hi, this was not previously a supermarket but a filling station. The objection to Tesco at Commonside is largely based on the danger to parents and school children going to Westways at this busy 5-ways junction. The extra traffic, including Tesco-proposed lorry delivery times of between 8am and 9am, just make this too dangerous a proposition for school children.

    • Thanks for this Bill. The reference to “if it was a supermarket before” refers to a Sainsbury’s mentioned in a thread running through the comments (and not the Tesco that’s the core subject of the post). I hope the original post covered the very valid points you make.

      Best wishes,

      NWS News Online

  2. Pingback: Commonside Tesco planning appeal update « North West Sheffield News Online

  3. I don’t know a lot about it, but I think as the building was previously a supermarket (it was once occupied by the Coop when the Coop was a Kwik Save) perhaps there was no need for planning permission, and hence no opportunity to object?

    • That seems to make sense, if it was a supermarket before …

      I also know there was strong (but unsuccessful) opposition to Tesco taking over the disused car showroom near Abbeydale Road (near Heeley Baths) and that certainly fits in with Tesco finding derelict – so presumably bargain-basement – sites to “develop”.

      Tesco’s agents handling the Commonside application know this news blog wants to know why they are appealing – in face of such strong local opposition (including Paul Scriven) and some apparently immovable reasons for refusal by Sheffield Council – but the promised return phone call still hasn’t transpired. A decision in favour of Tesco would seem to confirm FoE accusations about their corporate behaviour, moral scruples deficit and blatant disregard for local democracy.

  4. Somewhat ironically, Sainsburys new store (right next door to the Coop in crookes) will be opening on 10th Feb, amid absolutely no fuss at all.

  5. Pingback: Tweets that mention Controversial Commonside Tesco planning appeal lodged « North West Sheffield News Blog --

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s